As predicted, it didn’t take EA long to find a new way to gouge customers. They’ve tried several attempts at this project ten dollar BS and seem to have settled with the worst of a bad bunch of ideas.
In my opinion, a reasonable solution is how Battlefield Bad Company 2 was handled. All retail copies of the game came with a ‘VIP code’ that granted the owner free access to the first DLC pack. Any DLC since then, which has re-used assets on the disk, have also been free for ‘VIP’ players. Anyone buying used would have to fork out some extra cash to get access to the extra content. This at least seems half fair compared to the new system, which will see gamers buying used games forking over extra money to use the online features advertised on the back of the box.
Given that EA are one of the biggest game publishers around right now, I just don’t buy the claim they are losing money on used game sales. Not only that, but if their BS is to be believed, this is all for the benefit of the customers and to help fund upkeep of the servers.
Yes, but.. logically, the only strain on a server is caused by new retail players. Anyone who buys used is simply replacing a player that already existed and no longer uses the servers due to selling the game. Under this system, if the same game is sold and traded a couple of times, EA get paid multiple amounts towards the ‘upkeep of the servers’ yet they gain no additional players to justify it. I’m sorry but this just doesn’t wash.
If I sell my house, I don’t give a cut to the original builder because of work he did years ago – He was already paid for that work. If I were to sell a car, I wouldn’t give a cut to the manufacturer because they made it – They were already paid for the car when it was first bought.
BS, all of it.
I like to rent and ‘try-before-I-buy’ on some titles I’m unsure on. Under the new system, only the first in line to rent the game get to redeem any ‘VIP’ code included in the box which means anyone else renting that game will be restricted from the online features so that’s the end of that.
The worst of it is, if I know anything about gamers it’s that they’ll continue to buy even while being shafted. Example – the majority of the ‘Boycott MW2′ steam group were all tagged as playing MW2 on the day of release. Even though Activision makes games for Satan and his minions these days, gamers continue to support Kotick and his douchebaggery.
It’s simple logic that if EA can make this work, other publishers will start to pay attention. Ubisoft, Sega, and THQ already have plans to implement similar systems as I understand it… it wont be long before others fall in line with this if we don’t start voting with the contents of our wallets.